Judicial-Rebuke

Federal Judge Dismisses Indictments Against Letitia James and Comey, Ruling Halligan's Appointment Unlawful

| Importance: 10/10

U.S. District Judge Cameron McGowan Currie dismissed criminal indictments against New York Attorney General Letitia James and former FBI Director James Comey on November 24, 2025, ruling that interim U.S. Attorney Lindsey Halligan lacked lawful authority to bring the cases. In separate but parallel …

Cameron McGowan Currie Letitia James James Comey Lindsey Halligan Pam Bondi +5 more political-prosecution judicial-independence doj prosecutorial-misconduct retaliation +5 more
Read more →

Judge Finds Halligan Misrepresented Law and Used Tainted Evidence in Comey Grand Jury

| Importance: 9/10

Federal Magistrate Judge William Fitzpatrick issued a scathing ruling on November 17, 2025, finding that interim U.S. Attorney Lindsey Halligan may have fundamentally undermined the integrity of the grand jury proceedings against former FBI Director James Comey. In a devastating opinion, the judge …

William Fitzpatrick Lindsey Halligan James Comey Department of Justice FBI +2 more prosecutorial-misconduct fifth-amendment tainted-evidence judicial-rebuke doj-weaponization +2 more
Read more →

Federal Judge Rules Trump Administration Violated First Amendment by Forcing Partisan Auto-Reply Messages on Federal Employees

| Importance: 8/10

U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper ruled that the Trump administration violated the First Amendment by commandeering Education Department employees’ email accounts to send partisan messages blaming Democrats for the government shutdown. The automated responses stated that the House passed …

Christopher Cooper Department of Education American Federation of Government Employees first-amendment civil-service government-shutdown judicial-rebuke partisan-abuse
Read more →

Federal Judge Rules Border Patrol Commander Bovino Lied Under Oath, Issues Sweeping Use-of-Force Injunction

| Importance: 10/10

On November 6, 2025, U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis issued a devastating preliminary injunction against Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino and federal immigration enforcement agents in Chicago, explicitly finding that Bovino “admitted that he lied” about the October 23, 2025 tear gas …

Judge Sara Ellis Gregory Bovino Department of Homeland Security Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) +3 more gregory-bovino judge-sara-ellis judicial-rebuke perjury constitutional-violations +7 more
Read more →

FISA Court Judge Rejects NSA Warrantless Surveillance Expansion

| Importance: 8/10

FISA Court Judge Roger Vinson delivered a significant rebuke to the Bush administration by rejecting the government’s attempt to rewrite FISA statutes to permit expanded warrantless surveillance inside the United States. The government sought to stretch FISA’s definition of a …

Roger Vinson FISA Court NSA Bush Administration Department of Justice fisa-court judicial-rebuke warrantless-surveillance fourth-amendment constitutional-law +1 more
Read more →