Constitutional-Design

Constitution Entrenches Slavery Through Three-Fifths Compromise and Multiple Protections

| Importance: 10/10

The Constitutional Convention concludes its work by approving a Constitution that entrenches slavery through multiple provisions despite deliberately avoiding the word “slave” in the document. The most notorious provision is the Three-Fifths Compromise, proposed by delegate James Wilson …

Constitutional Convention James Wilson Charles Pinckney James Madison Southern slaveholders slavery institutional-corruption constitutional-design electoral-manipulation slave-power
Read more →

Electoral College Design Leverages Three-Fifths Compromise to Amplify Slave State Power

| Importance: 9/10

Constitutional Convention delegates finalize the Electoral College system for selecting presidents, resolving months of contentious debate between those favoring congressional selection and those supporting direct popular vote. The compromise creates an indirect election method where each state …

Constitutional Convention delegates James Madison Southern state delegates Committee of Eleven electoral-college three-fifths-compromise slavery institutional-corruption constitutional-design +1 more
Read more →

Constitutional Convention Adopts Fugitive Slave Clause Requiring Northern Complicity

| Importance: 9/10

On August 28, 1787, South Carolina delegates Pierce Butler and Charles Pinckney attempt unsuccessfully to include “fugitive slaves” in the Constitution’s extradition clause during Constitutional Convention debates. The following day, August 29, the South Carolina delegation …

Pierce Butler Charles Pinckney James Madison South Carolina delegates Committee of Style fugitive-slave-clause slavery constitutional-design institutional-corruption federal-complicity +1 more
Read more →

Constitutional Convention Guarantees 20-Year Protection for International Slave Trade

| Importance: 9/10

The Constitutional Convention’s Committee of Eleven, chaired by William Livingston of New Jersey, recommends prohibiting Congress from banning slave importation until 1808—initially proposing twelve years but extending to twenty years after southern delegates demand more time. This compromise, …

Committee of Eleven William Livingston John Rutledge Charles Pinckney Roger Sherman +2 more slavery slave-trade constitutional-design institutional-corruption slave-power +1 more
Read more →

Three-Fifths Compromise Gives Slaveholders Massive Extra Political Power

| Importance: 10/10

Delegates at the Constitutional Convention reach agreement on the Three-Fifths Compromise, proposed by James Wilson of Pennsylvania and seconded by Charles Pinckney of South Carolina, establishing that enslaved people will be counted as three-fifths of a person for purposes of congressional …

James Wilson Charles Pinckney Gouverneur Morris James Madison Southern state delegates +1 more three-fifths-compromise slavery institutional-corruption electoral-manipulation constitutional-design +1 more
Read more →

Haudenosaunee Confederacy: Democratic Practices Influencing Constitutional Design

| Importance: 9/10

The Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Confederacy demonstrated sophisticated democratic practices that significantly influenced American constitutional design, including consensus-based decision-making, gender-balanced leadership, and a complex system of checks and balances. Benjamin Franklin extensively …

Haudenosaunee Confederacy Benjamin Franklin Indigenous Leadership Clan Mothers Founding Fathers indigenous-democracy constitutional-design consensus-governance pre-colonial-democracy democratic-innovation
Read more →