Antitrust

Google Acquires DoubleClick for $3.1B, Creating Advertising Monopoly

| Importance: 10/10

On April 13, 2008, Google completed its $3.1 billion acquisition of DoubleClick, the dominant online advertising server and ad exchange operator. The merger, approved by the Federal Trade Commission in December 2007, combined Google’s search advertising dominance with DoubleClick’s …

Google DoubleClick Federal Trade Commission Pamela Jones Harbour (dissenting FTC Commissioner) David Rosenblatt (DoubleClick CEO) google doubleclick merger antitrust ftc +3 more
Read more →

AT&T Completes $86 Billion BellSouth Acquisition: Bell System Reassembled After 1984 Breakup

| Importance: 10/10

AT&T Inc. (formerly SBC Communications) completed its $85.8 billion acquisition of BellSouth Corporation with FCC approval, reassembling much of the former Bell System that was broken up in 1984 as an antitrust remedy. The merger consolidated control over telecommunications infrastructure across …

AT&T Inc. BellSouth Corporation Federal Communications Commission (FCC) SBC Communications antitrust consolidation merger telecommunications regulatory-capture +2 more
Read more →

Ares Management Acquires Aspen Dental: Private Equity Dental Roll-Up Strategy Launches Industry Consolidation

| Importance: 9/10

Private equity firm Ares Management acquired Aspen Dental in 2006, launching an aggressive roll-up strategy that would help consolidate the fragmented dental industry and establish the template for private equity’s systematic monopolization of healthcare sectors including dental, veterinary, …

Aspen Dental Ares Management Leonard Green & Partners American Securities antitrust consolidation private-equity dental healthcare +4 more
Read more →

Oracle Completes PeopleSoft Acquisition for $10.3 Billion After Defeating Antitrust Challenge

| Importance: 8/10

Oracle Corporation completed its acquisition of PeopleSoft on December 13, 2004, for approximately $10.3 billion ($26.50 per share), concluding an 18-month hostile takeover battle after defeating the Department of Justice’s antitrust challenge. The final purchase price represented more than …

Oracle Larry Ellison PeopleSoft JD Edwards oracle corporate-consolidation anti-competitive antitrust mergers
Read more →

Department of Justice Files Antitrust Lawsuit to Block Oracle-PeopleSoft Merger

| Importance: 8/10

The U.S. Department of Justice filed an antitrust lawsuit on February 26, 2004, seeking to block Oracle Corporation’s proposed hostile acquisition of PeopleSoft, alleging that the merger would substantially reduce competition in the enterprise software market and result in higher prices, less …

Department of Justice Oracle PeopleSoft Larry Ellison antitrust oracle corporate-consolidation doj competition
Read more →

Microsoft Antitrust Settlement Establishes Weak Precedent for Tech Monopolies

| Importance: 9/10

The U.S. Department of Justice reaches a settlement with Microsoft on November 1, 2001, abandoning the structural breakup remedy ordered by Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson in favor of behavioral restrictions. The Bush administration DOJ, after taking office in January 2001, announces on September 6, …

U.S. Department of Justice Microsoft Corporation George W. Bush John Ashcroft Bill Gates +1 more antitrust tech-monopoly regulatory-capture enforcement-failure corporate-power +2 more
Read more →

DOJ Files Microsoft Antitrust Suit, Establishes Tech Monopoly Precedent

| Importance: 9/10

The U.S. Department of Justice, joined by Attorneys General from 20 states and the District of Columbia, files antitrust charges against Microsoft on May 18, 1998, alleging the company violated the Sherman Act by using its operating system dominance to thwart competition. The complaint charges four …

U.S. Department of Justice Microsoft Corporation Bill Gates Joel Klein Janet Reno +1 more antitrust tech-monopoly regulatory-capture corporate-power enforcement-failure +1 more
Read more →

Boeing-McDonnell Douglas Merger Approved: Defense Contractor Consolidation Creates Oligopoly

| Importance: 10/10

The Federal Trade Commission approved Boeing’s $13.3 billion acquisition of McDonnell Douglas, completing a merger wave that reduced major U.S. defense contractors from 51 firms in the late 1980s to just five dominant primes by the late 1990s. The consolidation wave was actively encouraged by …

Boeing McDonnell Douglas Federal Trade Commission Department of Defense Les Aspin +1 more antitrust consolidation merger defense-contractors oligopoly +3 more
Read more →

DOJ Issues Baxter's 1982 Merger Guidelines, Revolutionizing Antitrust Enforcement Toward Corporate Permissiveness

| Importance: 10/10

Reagan’s Antitrust Chief William Baxter released the Department of Justice’s 1982 Merger Guidelines, fundamentally transforming how the federal government evaluated mergers and effectively repealing Congressional antitrust statutes through administrative policy. The FTC simultaneously …

William F. Baxter Department of Justice Federal Trade Commission Ronald Reagan antitrust regulatory-capture chicago-school merger-guidelines corporate-power +1 more
Read more →

AT&T Breakup Settlement Finalized, Becoming Last Major Antitrust Action for Decades

| Importance: 8/10

The Department of Justice and AT&T finalize the antitrust settlement requiring the telecommunications giant to divest its seven regional Bell operating companies (Baby Bells) in 1984, breaking up the AT&T natural monopoly. However, this settlement paradoxically marks the end rather than …

AT&T Department of Justice Ronald Reagan Robert Bork antitrust monopoly deregulation reagan-administration corporate-power
Read more →

Reagan Appoints William Baxter as Antitrust Chief, Enforcement Collapses as Chicago School Takes Control

| Importance: 10/10

President Ronald Reagan appointed Stanford Law Professor William F. Baxter as Assistant Attorney General for the Antitrust Division, marking the formal beginning of antitrust enforcement collapse and the operationalization of Chicago School ideology throughout the federal government. Baxter, a …

Ronald Reagan William F. Baxter Department of Justice Stanford Law School Senator Howard Metzenbaum antitrust regulatory-capture chicago-school reagan-administration enforcement-collapse +1 more
Read more →

Reagan Inauguration Begins Antitrust Revolution: Eight Years of Systematic Enforcement Collapse and Corporate Consolidation

| Importance: 10/10

Ronald Reagan’s inauguration marked the beginning of the most consequential transformation in American antitrust policy since the Sherman Act of 1890—an eight-year systematic dismantlement of competition enforcement that would enable four decades of corporate consolidation and monopolization. …

Ronald Reagan William F. Baxter Douglas Ginsburg Robert Bork Frank Easterbrook +3 more antitrust regulatory-capture chicago-school reagan-administration enforcement-collapse +2 more
Read more →

Hart-Scott-Rodino Act Requires Pre-Merger Notification, Last Major Antitrust Strengthening Before Reagan Dismantlement

| Importance: 9/10

President Gerald Ford signed the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act (HSR Act), requiring companies to notify the Federal Trade Commission and Department of Justice Antitrust Division of large proposed mergers and wait 30 days before consummating transactions, giving regulators time to …

Gerald Ford Senator Philip Hart Senator Hugh Scott Representative Peter Rodino Federal Trade Commission +1 more antitrust merger-enforcement regulatory-framework corporate-power premerger-notification
Read more →

FCC Adopts Seven-Station Rule Limiting Broadcast Ownership to Prevent Media Monopoly and Ensure Viewpoint Diversity

| Importance: 8/10

The Federal Communications Commission formally adopts the “seven-station rule” (Report and Order in Docket No. 8967, 18 F.C.C. 288) establishing that no single entity may own more than seven AM radio stations, seven FM radio stations, and seven television stations nationwide, with the …

Federal Communications Commission (FCC) media-regulation ownership-limits seven-station-rule fcc antitrust +2 more
Read more →

Celler-Kefauver Act Closes Merger Loopholes, Strengthens Government Power to Block Anticompetitive Consolidation

| Importance: 9/10

Congress passed the Celler-Kefauver Anti-Merger Act, championed by Representative Emanuel Celler (D-NY) and Senator Estes Kefauver (D-TN), fundamentally strengthening the Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914 and giving the government powerful new tools to prevent anticompetitive mergers. The Act closed …

U.S. Congress Representative Emanuel Celler Senator Estes Kefauver Harry Truman Federal Trade Commission antitrust merger-enforcement corporate-power competition cold-war
Read more →

FCC Establishes Television Ownership Limit of Three Stations to Prevent Media Monopoly Concentration

| Importance: 8/10

The Federal Communications Commission imposes the first national ownership restrictions for television stations at the dawn of the television industry, limiting any single entity from owning, operating, or controlling more than three television stations nationwide. The rule implements the …

Federal Communications Commission (FCC) media-regulation ownership-limits fcc television antitrust +1 more
Read more →

Temporary National Economic Committee Launches Comprehensive Investigation of Monopoly and Economic Concentration

| Importance: 7/10

Congress authorizes the Temporary National Economic Committee (TNEC) on June 16, 1938, launching the most comprehensive investigation of monopoly power and economic concentration in American history. Chaired by Senator Joseph O’Mahoney of Wyoming, the committee conducts three years of hearings …

Franklin D. Roosevelt Joseph O'Mahoney Thurman Arnold U.S. Congress major corporations antitrust monopoly corporate-concentration new-deal congressional-investigation
Read more →

FDR Warns Congress That Concentrated Corporate Power Threatens American Democracy with Fascism

| Importance: 8/10

On April 29, 1938, President Franklin D. Roosevelt sends a special message to Congress warning that concentrated corporate power poses an existential threat to American democracy, using language that explicitly links economic monopoly with the rise of fascism. Roosevelt declares that “the …

Franklin D. Roosevelt U.S. Congress concentrated corporate interests corporate-power fascism antitrust new-deal democracy +1 more
Read more →

Robinson-Patman Act Prohibits Price Discrimination to Protect Small Retailers from Chain Store Power

| Importance: 9/10

Congress passed the Robinson-Patman Act (RPA), co-sponsored by Senator Joseph T. Robinson (D-AR) and Representative Wright Patman (D-TX), prohibiting anticompetitive price discrimination by producers. The law responded to the growing power of chain stores like the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea …

U.S. Congress Senator Joseph T. Robinson Representative Wright Patman Federal Trade Commission antitrust regulatory-capture price-discrimination corporate-power small-business
Read more →

Supreme Court Applies Antitrust Law to Union Secondary Boycotts in Bedford Cut Stone

| Importance: 8/10

The Supreme Court rules that the Journeymen Stone Cutters Association of North America violated the Sherman Antitrust Act by declaring stone from Bedford Cut Stone Company and 23 other Indiana limestone producers “unfair” and prohibiting its 5,000 members from working on buildings using …

George Sutherland U.S. Supreme Court Journeymen Stone Cutters Association Bedford Cut Stone Company labor-suppression judicial-capture anti-union antitrust
Read more →

Supreme Court Reverses Coronado Decision, Opens Unions to Antitrust Liability

| Importance: 9/10

The Supreme Court unanimously reverses its 1922 Coronado decision, ruling that the United Mine Workers local union violated the Sherman Antitrust Act by conspiring to restrain interstate commerce in coal. After the Court’s first ruling favored the union by finding insufficient evidence of …

William Howard Taft U.S. Supreme Court United Mine Workers of America Coronado Coal Company labor-suppression judicial-capture anti-union antitrust
Read more →

Supreme Court Rules Unincorporated Unions Can Be Sued in Coronado Coal Case

| Importance: 7/10

The Supreme Court rules in United Mine Workers v. Coronado Coal Co. that unincorporated labor unions can be sued in federal court as legal entities, establishing a precedent that exposes unions to potentially devastating civil liability. The case arises from Arkansas’s Sebastian County Union …

William Howard Taft U.S. Supreme Court United Mine Workers of America Coronado Coal Company labor-suppression judicial-capture anti-union antitrust
Read more →

Supreme Court Guts Clayton Act Labor Protections in Duplex Printing Decision

| Importance: 8/10

The Supreme Court rules 6-3 in Duplex Printing Press Co. v. Deering that the Clayton Act’s supposed protections for labor organizing do not prevent federal courts from enjoining union boycotts. Justice Mahlon Pitney holds that Section 20 of the Clayton Act, which labor had celebrated in 1914 …

Mahlon Pitney U.S. Supreme Court International Association of Machinists Duplex Printing Press Company labor-suppression judicial-capture antitrust supreme-court clayton-act
Read more →

Supreme Court Dismisses U.S. Steel Antitrust Case, Ruling Size Alone Not Illegal - Enforcement Ends Until 1945

| Importance: 10/10

The U.S. Supreme Court, in a 4-3 decision written by Justice Joseph McKenna, dismissed the government’s antitrust case against U.S. Steel Corporation, the world’s first billion-dollar company created through J.P. Morgan’s 1901 merger. The Court ruled: “We must adhere to the …

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Joseph McKenna Justice Day U.S. Steel Corporation Elbert Henry Gary antitrust rule-of-reason corporate-power supreme-court enforcement-abandonment +1 more
Read more →

Clayton Antitrust Act Signed: Labor Unions Exempted from Antitrust Laws, Gompers Calls It Labor's Magna Carta

| Importance: 9/10

President Woodrow Wilson signed the Clayton Antitrust Act, enhancing previous antitrust legislation and explicitly exempting labor unions from antitrust laws. Alabama Democrat Henry De Lamar Clayton Jr. introduced the legislation in anticipation of the Commission on Industrial Relations report. The …

President Woodrow Wilson Henry De Lamar Clayton Jr. Samuel Gompers American Federation of Labor E. Y. Webb progressive-era antitrust labor-organizing regulatory-reform
Read more →

Wilson Signs Federal Trade Commission Act, Creating Expert Antitrust Enforcement Agency

| Importance: 9/10

President Woodrow Wilson signed the Federal Trade Commission Act into law, establishing the FTC as an independent federal agency to prevent ‘unfair methods of competition’ and protect consumers from deceptive business practices. The Act fulfilled Wilson’s ‘New Freedom’ …

Woodrow Wilson Federal Trade Commission U.S. Congress antitrust regulatory-enforcement federal-trade-commission progressive-era corporate-power
Read more →

DuPont Powder Trust Ordered Dissolved, But Family Control and Geographic Proximity Limit Effectiveness

| Importance: 7/10

Following a 1911 Sherman Antitrust Act lawsuit, the U.S. District Court for Delaware ordered the DuPont Powder Company dissolved and divided into three independent entities: the reconstituted DuPont, Hercules Powder Company, and Atlas Powder Company. DuPont had controlled approximately two-thirds of …

U.S. District Court for Delaware E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Company DuPont family Hercules Powder Company Atlas Powder Company antitrust corporate-power enforcement-limitations dupont powder-trust
Read more →

Supreme Court Orders American Tobacco Breakup, Applying Rule of Reason to Tobacco Trust

| Importance: 9/10

The U.S. Supreme Court, in a 9-0 unanimous decision applying the new “rule of reason” doctrine, ruled that the American Tobacco Company violated the Sherman Antitrust Act and ordered the tobacco trust dissolved. Founded in 1890 by James Duke, American Tobacco controlled nearly 90% of …

U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice Edward White American Tobacco Company James Duke antitrust corporate-power supreme-court monopoly rule-of-reason +1 more
Read more →

Standard Oil Breakup's Paradox - Rockefeller's Wealth Triples as Fragmented Companies Reconsolidate

| Importance: 9/10

The Supreme Court’s order to break Standard Oil into 34 separate companies produced a profound paradox: the breakup made John D. Rockefeller vastly richer while ultimately failing to prevent reconsolidation. Shareholders in Standard Oil received proportional stakes in each successor …

John D. Rockefeller Standard Oil Company U.S. Supreme Court antitrust corporate-power wealth-concentration monopoly enforcement-limitations
Read more →

Buck's Stove Case: Gompers, Mitchell, Morrison Sentenced for Contempt, Boycotts Criminalized

| Importance: 7/10

A federal court sentenced AFL President Samuel Gompers to one year in prison, Vice President John Mitchell to nine months, and Secretary Frank Morrison to six months for contempt of court in the Buck’s Stove and Range Company boycott case. The case exemplified how federal courts had become …

Samuel Gompers John Mitchell Frank Morrison American Federation of Labor Buck's Stove and Range Company +1 more labor-suppression judicial-capture progressive-era antitrust injunctions
Read more →

Roosevelt Leaves Office After 44 Antitrust Suits, Revealing Progressive Era Reform Limits

| Importance: 8/10

When Theodore Roosevelt left office on March 4, 1909, his administration had filed 44 antitrust lawsuits (18 civil and 26 criminal cases, resulting in 22 convictions and 22 acquittals) against major corporations including Northern Securities, Standard Oil, American Tobacco, the Beef Trust, and Du …

Theodore Roosevelt William Howard Taft J.P. Morgan U.S. Department of Justice Interstate Commerce Commission antitrust corporate-power progressive-era regulatory-enforcement presidential-legacy
Read more →

Roosevelt Approves U.S. Steel Acquisition of Tennessee Coal & Iron During Panic, Exposing Reform Limits

| Importance: 9/10

On the morning of Saturday, November 2, 1907, during the Panic of 1907 financial crisis, J.P. Morgan convened a meeting at his library proposing that U.S. Steel—which already controlled 60% of the steel market—purchase stock in the insolvent brokerage firm Moore & Schley, which had borrowed …

Theodore Roosevelt J.P. Morgan Elbert H. Gary Henry Clay Frick U.S. Steel Corporation +2 more antitrust corporate-power financial-crisis progressive-era regulatory-capture
Read more →

Roosevelt Justice Department Files Antitrust Suit Against American Tobacco Trust

| Importance: 8/10

On July 19, 1907, the Roosevelt administration’s Department of Justice filed a major antitrust petition against the American Tobacco Company after one of its subsidiaries was indicted for price-fixing in the Southern District of New York. The suit charged sixty-five companies and twenty-nine …

Theodore Roosevelt U.S. Department of Justice American Tobacco Company James Buchanan Duke antitrust corporate-power regulatory-enforcement progressive-era monopoly
Read more →

Supreme Court Rules Against Beef Trust, Establishes Stream of Commerce Doctrine

| Importance: 8/10

On January 30, 1905, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Swift & Co. v. United States that the Commerce Clause allowed the federal government to regulate monopolies that have a direct effect on interstate commerce, dealing a major blow to the “Beef Trust” cartel. The case followed …

U.S. Supreme Court Swift & Company Armour & Company Theodore Roosevelt Attorney General Philander Knox antitrust corporate-power supreme-court regulatory-enforcement progressive-era
Read more →

Supreme Court Orders Northern Securities Dissolution in First Major Antitrust Victory

| Importance: 10/10

On March 14, 1904, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that the Northern Securities Company violated the Sherman Antitrust Act and ordered the railroad holding company dissolved. The decision affirmed the April 9, 1903 federal circuit court ruling against the company formed by J.P. Morgan, James J. …

U.S. Supreme Court Theodore Roosevelt J.P. Morgan James J. Hill Edward H. Harriman +1 more antitrust corporate-power regulatory-enforcement supreme-court progressive-era
Read more →

Roosevelt Signs Elkins Act Prohibiting Railroad Rebates and Price Discrimination

| Importance: 7/10

On February 19, 1903, President Theodore Roosevelt signed the Elkins Act, which made it a federal misdemeanor for railroads to grant rebates or preferential rates and held both the carrier and the recipient liable. The Act was sponsored by Senator Stephen B. Elkins of West Virginia and introduced in …

Theodore Roosevelt Senator Stephen B. Elkins Interstate Commerce Commission Pennsylvania Railroad Railroad companies antitrust railroad-regulation progressive-era regulatory-enforcement
Read more →

Roosevelt Creates Bureau of Corporations and Department of Commerce and Labor

| Importance: 8/10

On February 14, 1903, President Theodore Roosevelt signed the Act to Establish the Department of Commerce and Labor, creating the ninth cabinet-level executive department and establishing the Bureau of Corporations as an investigatory agency within it. The Bureau was specifically designed to study …

Theodore Roosevelt U.S. Congress George B. Cortelyou James Rudolph Garfield Bureau of Corporations antitrust regulatory-enforcement progressive-era corporate-power institutional-expansion
Read more →

Ida Tarbell Begins "The History of the Standard Oil Company" in McClure's Magazine

| Importance: 9/10

Ida Tarbell began publishing her groundbreaking 19-part investigative series “The History of the Standard Oil Company” in McClure’s Magazine in November 1902, running through October 1904. Her meticulous research exposed the predatory business practices, illegal rebate schemes, and …

Ida Tarbell McClure's Magazine Standard Oil Company John D. Rockefeller investigative-journalism muckraking corporate-power antitrust media +1 more
Read more →

Justice Department Files Antitrust Suit Against Beef Trust Monopoly

| Importance: 8/10

In May 1902, while the Northern Securities case proceeded through the courts, Attorney General Philander Knox filed a second major antitrust suit under President Theodore Roosevelt against the “Beef Trust”—a cartel of six major meatpacking companies (Swift, Armour, Morris, Cudahy, …

Theodore Roosevelt Attorney General Philander Knox Swift & Company Armour & Company Morris & Company +2 more antitrust corporate-power regulatory-enforcement progressive-era food-industry
Read more →

Roosevelt Announces Northern Securities Antitrust Suit Against J.P. Morgan Railroad Trust

| Importance: 9/10

On February 19, 1902, President Theodore Roosevelt’s Department of Justice announced plans to file an antitrust suit against the Northern Securities Company, a railroad holding company formed in November 1901 by J.P. Morgan, James J. Hill, and Edward H. Harriman to control the Great Northern …

Theodore Roosevelt Attorney General Philander Knox J.P. Morgan James J. Hill Edward H. Harriman +1 more antitrust corporate-power regulatory-enforcement progressive-era railroad-regulation
Read more →

Sherman Antitrust Act Passed but Designed for Non-Enforcement Against Monopolies

| Importance: 10/10

On July 2, 1890, President Benjamin Harrison signed the Sherman Antitrust Act into law after it passed the Senate 51-1 (April 8) and the House 242-0 (June 20), creating America’s first federal anti-monopoly legislation—but the law was deliberately vague, weakly worded, and systematically …

Senator John Sherman President Benjamin Harrison U.S. Congress antitrust regulatory-failure political-theater gilded-age corporate-power
Read more →